Saturday, August 13, 2022

Standardized testing problematic

The responsibility of falling college graduation rates does not fall upon the students, but rather overqualified professors — at least that’s what Marky Nemko, a Ph.D in education evaluation, argues in an article he wrote for Time magazine’s website.

Throughout his article, Nemko suggests the intelligence gap between Ph.D-wielding professors and undergraduate students is too great for students to properly learn. Additionally, he said if a student did not have above average grades in high school, he or she should consider an alternative to a college education.

Plattsburgh State Honors Program Director and Anthropology Professor James Armstrong said it makes sense that some Ph.D.s may not make good teachers, but intelligence level is not to blame. Instead, he said it boils down to the teacher’s willingness to teach well.

Armstrong said the problem makes more sense at a big-name research university where professors are more interested in research than teaching. But at colleges like PSUC, he noted that there is more of an emphasis on teaching.

“That isn’t to say every college professor here is a great teacher, but it is to say most people here care about teaching,” Armstrong said. “At a school like this, most Ph.D.s who work here are mostly good teachers.”

Rather than looking at college education solely from a classroom standpoint, Armstrong said there are multiple other factors that contribute to a student’s college learning experience, and students should grow from what they learn from activities outside the classroom.

“College is multi-dimensional,” Armstrong said. “They take the attitude that learning is instrumental — that the whole purpose of going to college is to learn stuff for a job. That is not what college is about. That is not what college should be about. If that is the direction college goes, we’re doomed.”

Armstrong blames the nation’s overemphasis on standardized testing in primary and secondary education as to why some students put their entire focus on class work within their majors. He added that it’s difficult for students to transition from a grade school routine of answering questions to a college environment where they are more encouraged to ask the questions.

“That is a difficult transition to make,” he said. “Test-driven education in secondary education is a disaster. It’s reductive. It doesn’t broaden a person’s perspective, it narrows it.”

Mark Beatham, associate professor of teacher education, said professors need to be able to think like their students in order to teach, and the gap between students and professors is more cultural than it is intelligence.

Beatham also echoed Armstrong’s concerns with revolving high school education around testing, saying they measure a student’s intellectual value too early in his or her life and closes potential opportunities.

“One of the worst criticisms of education whether its college or high school is that we too often teach children to give themselves a price before they understand their value,” Beatham said. “I think it’s a diminished sense of human possibility.”

Email Brian Molongoski at

- Advertisment -


Baseball breaks playoff drought

By Colin Bolebruch For the first time in a decade, the Plattsburgh Cardinals men’s baseball team is playoff-bound. This past weekend the Cardinals eked out a...

Cardinals Beat Saints

By Melanie Lanzo St. Lawrence University and the Plattsburgh Cardinals have a long history with previous back-to-back losses the Cardinals have experienced back in 2021....

Rugby punches ticket to nations

By Liam Sample The Plattsburgh men’s rugby team’s “miracle” run continued as they finished the regular season by winning the TNT Tournament at Memorial Field...

New, old clubs expand campus culture

By Sydney Hakes While higher education is a place for fine tuning one’s skills and defining career goals, campus life plays an important role in...